Mariners Roster Set for 2025: A Make-or-Break Season?
According to Adam Jude of The Seattle Times, the Mariners’ recent signing of Jorge Polanco has effectively finalized their Opening Day roster. While nothing is set in stone, a projected lineup has taken shape:
Victor Robles, RF
Julio Rodríguez, CF
Cal Raleigh, C
Randy Arozarena, LF
Luke Raley, 1B
Jorge Polanco, 3B
Donovan Solano, DH
J.P. Crawford, SS
Dylan Moore, 2B
Of course, this is merely one iteration of the lineup we could see throughout the season. There’s room for adjustment—perhaps Mitch Garver or Mitch Haniger slots in at DH instead of Solano, or Cal Raleigh moves into the cleanup spot while J.P. Crawford shifts within the order. But beyond the specifics of batting order, the more pressing question is: Are the Mariners truly set up for success?
On the surface, this lineup suggests a commitment to continuity. Aside from Solano, Seattle is essentially running back the same team that fell just short of the playoffs in 2024. The organization is clearly banking on internal improvements, a full season of lineup chemistry, and a strong carryover from last year’s late-season push. If this strategy pays off, the front office will look like visionaries, having placed their faith in a roster primed to take the next step.
However, if it falters, the consequences could be seismic. A lackluster season could erode fan support and amplify criticism directed at ownership. Worse yet, it could force sweeping changes across the organization—front office shakeups, coaching turnover, and a roster overhaul that alters the trajectory of the franchise for years to come.
The 2025 season is poised to be one of the most pivotal in recent Mariners history. Success could validate this approach and establish Seattle as a legitimate contender. Failure, on the other hand, could usher in an era of uncertainty and restructuring. One thing is certain: the stakes have never been higher.
